But Women of the Wall chairperson Anat Hoffman criticized the lack of political response to the treatment that Frenkel received. “I want Michael Oren to be drowning in e-mails and faxes and letters saying: ‘Do something about this. This is something we care about,’” said Hoffman, who is also executive director of the Reform movement’s Israel Religious Action Center.
Hoffman said that when she led the women in Rosh Hodesh prayer at Kotel, she heard ultra-Orthodox men jeering them, calling them “prostitutes” and shouting that “the Holocaust happened because of you.”
“But more than I heard the bullies, I heard the silence of all my supporters,” Hoffman said. “The silence of the majority of Israeli seculars, who have allowed this thing to happen; the silence of the court, the police, the mayor, the Knesset, and also the silence of my brothers and sisters, who know women read Torah and wear tallit.”
There is a struggle going on for the very soul of Israel, and of Judaism itself. Only one side, however, appears to be fully engaged in this struggle, while the other appears to be largely unaware that the struggle is even taking place (still less what the stakes are).
On the one side are ranged all the forces of ultra-Orthodoxy, fundamentalism, theocracy, backwardness, pseudo-Halacha, ultra-nationalism and xenophobia, corruption and the sternest notions of what constitutes Judaism. This "Black Hat Judaism" would like to see an Israel encompassing the entire Land of Israel, ruled by those who claim to speak in the name of God, at war with the entire world for a brief while; until it vanishes for the same reasons as did the 2nd Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine. It is determined to reverse the revolutions in Jewish life brought about by the Emancipation, Enlightenment and Zionism, and appears intent on turning the Jewish world into a grim Kehilla or Shtetl writ large, without dissent or diversity.
On the other side we find openness, pluralism, tolerance, acceptance, learning, scholarship and science and the idea that Judaism is there to sanctify life, not replace it. This "White Hat Judaism" sees Israel as a full member of the family of nations; a state that is both Jewish and democratic. A state that upholds ideals of social justice and that allows all faiths - and all branches of the Jewish faith - to flourish.
This monumental struggle closely resembles that between the democratic and totalitarian worlds, which dominated much of the 20th Century. Let's hope that the democratic Jewish world wakes up, before it's too late!
In the context of this struggle, the distinctions between Conservative/Masorti, Liberal, Progressive, Reconstructionist, Reform and Secular Humanist Judaism no longer count. All that matters is for everyone who sees themselves as part of the Jewish democratic camp to support the individuals and organisations (such as Hiddush (Freedom Of Religion for Israel), IRAC and the New Israel Fund (NIF) that are in the vanguard of the struggle against the black tide sweeping through the Jewish world today.